Massachusetts foster parents lose license over refusal to affirm LGBTQ policy
A couple in Woburn, Massachusetts recently lost their foster license after refusing to sign a gender-affirming nondiscrimination policy required by the state’s Department of Children and Families. The policy mandates that foster parents affirm a child’s sexual orientation, gender identity, and expression. The couple, Lydia and Heath Marvin, say they declined the policy in obedience to their Christian faith.
The Marvins had cared for children under four years old since 2020 and had previously fostered eight infants. Their most recent placement involved a baby with complex medical needs who lived in their home for 15 months. When they were asked to sign the new policy, they attempted to request accommodations, but were told they must sign it as is or lose their license.
Supporters of the Marvins argue that the policy infringes on religious liberty by compelling speech and actions that conflict with sincere beliefs. The couple has appealed the revocation of their license and indicated they may pursue further legal options. Other foster families in Massachusetts have joined similar challenges in federal court, arguing that the state’s policy effectively forces them to violate their beliefs or be excluded from care.
LGBTQ advocates, conversely, defend the policy as essential to protect vulnerable children in foster care. They argue that requiring foster caregivers to respect a child’s identity helps safeguard emotional health, especially for LGBTQ youth who already face higher risks of mental health challenges and rejection.
Massachusetts’ policy reflects a growing national trend toward requiring foster and adoptive parents to commit to nondiscrimination. Some legal analysts say the outcome of this dispute may hinge on how courts balance religious rights against state interests in child welfare.
